Players picked for England on reputation or form? Clearly there will be players that will be picked on reputation such as JJB, Wilkin, Morley, Briscoe and McNamaras love child Sinfield which infuriates me as players such as Matty Smith, Jodie Broughton, Daryl CLark, Craig Huby, Danny Kirmond who deserve international recognition. However some of them don't play for the big clubs so don't deserve the chance even though they play better than some of the out of form players that do play for the big clubs.

It should be a mix of form and reputation/experience.

Considering no one has any kind of stellar international reputation then you might as well go with form

You need the best team and tag should be a mix of established players and form players, just throwing all the in form players together won't give you the best team, just because they are playing well for their club goest mean they will automatically show that form when thrown into a new team environment.

Reading between the lines, another anti Sinfield post.
Hope Sinfield pulls out of the world cup or is not picked, because when England do not win it, he will take the blame regardless of performance.

Doesn't matter now, Brough has rightly chosen to stick with Scotland so if or when England dont win the final it will all be either because Sinfield played or Brough didn't

Perfect all round for the knee jerkers on here.

No when we lose it will be because MacNamara picked mediocre players with a proven record of failure at international level, whose season long form has been mediocre and ignored players who have shown time and time again they are match winners

From the bulls to England he has shown himself to be very very sub standard as a coach

International rugby league is a joke anyway - there is Australia and NZ followed a long way by England with the rest making up the (even then, rather poor) numbers.

I think it's a perfect job for someone like him who can't coach. Easy to explain when we don't win but absolutely no chance of doing worse than 3rd.

Who are these 'match winners' he's left out?

Anyone but JJB, Ablett, Wilkin etc etc

Specifically the likes of Brough, Biers

JJB & Ablett arn't proven match winners?

The Welsh Lee Briers?

Like the Scottish Danny Brough - opted to play for them because of constantly being overlooked by England

Right Brough and Briers (who's blatantly always chosen wales so not sure where your argument for him is) are the proven match winners. Lets look at the current half backs in the England squad against your proven match winner.

Brough - 1 CC winners medal in 2005

Widdop - 1 Minor NRL premership, 1 NRL Premiership, 1 WCC winners medal

Chase - Nowt Ill give you that but he has got a MOS award

Myler - 2 CC winners medals, Hubcap winners medal

Rob Burrow - 3 WCC winners medals, 6 SL winners medals, 1 Harry sunderland trophy

Danny Mcguire - 3 WCC winners medals, 6 SL winners medals.

I wont bother with Sinfield as I think you get the drift, your proven match winner isn't really a proven match winner is he, he's a very talented halfback who's having a blinder of a season (so far) but don't over play his hand as a proven match winner. And dont say Mcnamara is shunning match winners when he clearly is doing the opposite.