Put his time here, side by side with Adrian Morley, who's been the better prop?

I'd say Chilly, i'd say he's stepped his game up even more, following the Man of Steel nominee announcements, which makes it even more of a joke.

The signing of Moz put us on the path to being a 'big club' but Hill is something else as a player. He is like a rugby terminator, relentless and unbreakable.

Best warrington prop ive ever seen. He's surpassed morley, boyd and....teitzel. The man is utter class.

Chris Hill for mine. Dont get me wrong I loved the rough and tumble that you got with a player like Adrian Morley, but you just get the no nonsense prop forward work out of Hilly.

Inspired decision making him the captain. Leads from the front with a do as i do attitude.

Hill is certainly better in my opinion, I enjoyed watching Morley though for the big hits.

I actually think our pack outside of Hill isn't great, if we lost him we would really struggle for go forward.

I'm not a Sims fan but he tackled relentlessly last night. All of Saints points were scored when Hill went off. We need another quality prop to accompany Hill, Sims and Cooper. The size of the Saints pack vs ours was incredible.

Hill has made the difference this year. Considering our lack of seasoned props through injury this year we have done really well to finish top & get to 2 finals. Hilly has been head & shoulders above the rest & made valuable yards that mattered.

Man of Graphene for the 21st century.

Sims has a great attitude and work rate, rarely gets injured and plays long minutes, so he is certainly a good player to have.

But he would struggle to break through a paper bag at times, so like you say, another quality prop is needed.

Sims does a particular job and does it very well, quick ptb, good offloads (mostly)and very good defence...he was very, very good last night and i think he's had a very good season. Gets a bit of stick for not being chris hill but there's no shame in that.

I watched the game again on Sky when I got home. They mentioned that Walmsley has 76 tackle busts the season, 2nd highest for a prop after Junior Moors (85). In comparison Sims has 18. Matt Russel has a colossal 126. I can see now why he get's the nod by TS.

Sims was top offloader in the league this year, its swings and roundabouts.


btw, that amazed me when i heard on sky last week about him being top offloader in the league.

yes Russell gets stick at times on here because he is not seen as an out and out winger, but the go forward he gives us is invaluable... gets good metres coupled with quick play the ball, and that makes huge difference to the whole set.