Quote SmokeyTA="SmokeyTA"The question I'm guessing being 6 grand final wins, 7grand finals, 3 Wcc, 4 cc finals, with a team of home grown stars, who have then slowly but surely been replaced, now blooding more top quality youngsters in Sutcliffe, Ward, foster and minns to join The like is Watkins and hardaker McShane and Clarkson, what on earth do we need to do to earn the trust of our fan base so that every time a decent youngster leaves our judgement isn't 'seriously questioned'?'"
Try and seperate the things then you might understand.
Put the trophy success aside, you have to because the academy is future, not 2004,2007,2008,2009, or even 2011 and 2012. The academy is going forward.
Baldwinson is a blow to lose. To add Tonks is massive. They even sent Tonks over to Australia the other year to aid his development, he was that highly thought of. He might well never have made it, but he was part of there strategy.
If you are losing your future identified stars due to not tying them up, then you need to ask serious questions about how these things happen. Hull did the exact thing after losing Briscoe,
It doesn't matter about previous or current success. If you set out a strategy to promote from within and maintain success, if you lose parts of that strategy you hit a problem going forward.
At end of last season, I posted that Baldwinson, Tonks, Foster, and Minchella should be what our future pack is built with, and should be introduced this year and build development. As far as I am aware the club was also looking that way. To lose half of those players now is surely a blow to them. Therefore any self respecting business would ask questions of themselves and put things in place to ensure it doesn't happen again. Remember the academy is a seperate side to the business from the first team. It's job is to provide a pool of players equipped for 1st team, and usually that is built up over a few years.