What do you all make of this ?

[urlhttp://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/league/5999505/Kiwis-hooker-Luke-I-tried-to-break-his-leg[/url

=#FF0000link changed to the actual copyright holder rather than some blogger who simply nicked the content. tb

Blah blah - he's a horrid little thug who should be serving a long ban.

Had he done it to a the star Wakey player, I'm sure your tone would be different.

Actually, I think Bren was actually sticking up for Chase there. Perhaps you misread it?

Looked sarky to me. If not I apologise.

I was referring to his comments in the article; as I said at the time, his attack on Chase was a disgusting act of cowardice for which he should be facing a long ban.

It may surprise you to know that I have nothing against Chase - he's a very talented player and is the type of import who adds value to SL, without question; he isn't English though, nor is he good enough to play at international level.

Please enlighten us on who you feel to be a better eligible stand-off than the current Man of Steel and Goldthorpe Medal holder?

Stay on topic please - this thread is about the filthy attitude of Isaac Luke, who seems to coast from one disciplinary to another, publicly acknowledging his intent to hurt opposition players, but faces no substantive consequences for his actions.

It's a joke, but not a very funny one.

I think you are the one who digressed the topic.....



but when asked to back up what you say are unable to do so.

Happy to discuss it on the relevant thread - I don't contribute to thread drift or derailling.

HTH.

I have to stick up for Brenk here, he made a reasonable comment in keeping with the thread subject and had the same thing been said by a known Cas fan nobody would have taken issue with it.

At least Luke has admitted that what he did was wrong and that he needs to mend his ways. Seems like someone who has a tendency to see the redmist on the pitch.

Good on Rangi for being the bigger man and saying that any disagreements stay on the pitch. Some of the big earning wendyball players could take a leaf out of his book....

Big respect to rangi for being the better man but i do think
More should be done to isaac luke punishment wise itsok saying it stays on the pitch but had luke made good on his intentions what would be said then.just such a horrible little man